I’ve had many conversations this past week on a topic that most all of us need to hear. That topic? Not “fully” deciding, but rather having one foot in the pool and one foot on the deck. It doesn’t make for a good swim. So let’s talk about why you keep starting over… and the psychology of half-committing.
Half-decisions are the most exhausting thing we do to ourselves.
Not the hard decisions or wrong decisions. The half ones. I’m talking about the ones where we tell ourselves we’re committed while simultaneously making sure we have an exit strategy. The ones where we start something new while mentally holding onto the option of going back.
That kind of ambiguity doesn’t feel like flexibility. It feels like freedom. But what it actually does is put your brain in a state of permanent low-grade negotiation. And that negotiation is exhausting in a way that most people don’t even realize is happening, because they’ve been doing it for so long it’s become the background noise of their daily life.
This week I want to talk about why clarity is one of the kindest things you can give yourself, and what it actually costs to keep living in the gray area of your own decisions.
The Science Behind Why Half-Decisions Drain You
Roy Baumeister’s research on decision fatigue is some of the most important work in behavioral psychology of the last three decades. His studies consistently show that the act of making decisions depletes a measurable cognitive resource. The more decisions you make, the less mental energy you have available for everything else. And crucially, revisiting the same decision over and over, because you never fully made it the first time, costs you every single time.
There’s also something called the Zeigarnik effect, named after psychologist Bluma Zeigarnik, who discovered in the 1920s that the human brain holds onto unfinished business differently than it holds onto completed tasks. Unresolved decisions stay active in your working memory, surfacing repeatedly, pulling your attention back, creating a kind of mental background hum that never fully goes away. You’re not consciously thinking about the thing you haven’t decided. But it’s there. Taking up space. Using energy.
Which means the thing you’ve been going back and forth about, the habit you keep starting and stopping, the change you keep circling but not committing to, is costing you cognitive resources every single day whether you’re actively thinking about it or not. And that cost doesn’t show up on any lab result or in any obvious place. It just quietly depletes the reserves you need for everything else in your life.
Ambiguity feels like keeping your options open. What it actually does is keep you in a permanent state of deciding, which is one of the most draining places a human being can live.
What Half-Commitment Actually Looks Like
I want to give specific examples here because I think this pattern shows up in more places than most people realize.
The job you keep saying you’ll leave.
You’ve been unhappy for two years. You talk about it. You update your resume. You have a few conversations. But you never fully commit to going or fully commit to staying and making it work. So you exist in this suspended middle state, neither fully present in the role you have nor fully pursuing the one you want. And that in-between is its own kind of miserable.
The health habit you start every Monday.
Sunday night you’re motivated. You meal prep, you set the alarm, you’re ready. But somewhere in the back of your mind you know that if this week gets hard enough, the habit is optional. And so the first Wednesday when life doesn’t cooperate, the option presents itself and you take it. And then Sunday you start again. And the cycle is so familiar it’s become invisible! This is a very common theme when it comes to drinking… and it’s exhausting.
The relationship pattern you keep returning to.
Maybe it’s a dynamic with a spouse, a family member, or a friend that you know isn’t healthy. You pull back. You set a boundary. And then something softens and you find yourself back in the same place, because you never fully decided what you were actually willing to accept and what you weren’t.
The conversation you keep putting off.
You know it needs to happen. You’ve been carrying it for months, maybe longer. And because you haven’t had it, everything around that relationship has a slightly unresolved quality that you’ve just learned to live with. That’s the Zeigarnik effect in action. The unfinished thing staying open, drawing attention, using energy.
What all of these have in common is not weakness or lack of discipline. It’s the absence of a full decision. And a full decision isn’t about having certainty or being fearless. It’s about closing the negotiation with yourself so your brain can stop running the calculation every day.
Why Clarity Is Kindness
Here’s a reframe I want to offer you this week. But first, I need to give credit to Dave Ramsey for the term, “Being unclear is being unkind.” I believe this coincides quite nicely to our theme this week. That when you commit fully to something, it’s not rigid or extreme. It’s actually one of the most compassionate things you can do for yourself.
When you make a real decision, not a tentative one with exit ramps built in, something shifts neurologically. The brain stops holding the question open. The background negotiation ends. And all the energy that was going into managing the ambiguity becomes available for actually living the decision.
Psychologist Peter Gollwitzer has spent decades studying what he calls implementation intentions, which are specific if-then commitments as opposed to vague goal-setting. His research consistently shows that people who make specific, concrete commitments follow through at dramatically higher rates than people who set general intentions. The specificity of the commitment closes the space where negotiation lives. And when there is no space for negotiation, the behavior becomes almost automatic.
This is why, “I am going to try to work out more”, produces different results than “I go to the gym on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday, no matter what.” One leaves room for the conversation. The other does not. And the one that does not is actually the kinder thing to do to yourself, because it removes a daily decision that was costing you energy. Makes a lot of sense, right?
The Identity Piece
Most of the time when we can’t fully commit to a change, it’s not because we don’t want the result. It’s because the change requires us to let go of an identity we’ve been holding onto.
The person who doesn’t commit to leaving the job is still protecting the identity of someone who could handle it if they wanted to. The person who keeps restarting the health habit is still holding the story that they’re someone who will get serious about this eventually. And so on.
Real commitment requires a shift in how you see yourself, not just in what you do. And that shift is uncomfortable because it asks you to release a story you’ve been telling for a long time. But here’s what I know after ten years of this work: the discomfort of releasing the old story is temporary. The exhaustion of carrying it indefinitely is not.
You can keep cycling if you want. You can keep starting over. But at some point the question becomes: what is the cost of staying in the gray area of this decision? And is that cost worth it?
This Week on Beyond the Gray
Episode 30 drops Tuesday and I address what I’ve been sharing here… specifically when it comes to drinking. I share the data on what actually changes when someone fully decides rather than negotiating with themselves. It’s going to resonate with a lot of people who’ve been going in circles on something they already know the answer to. Tune in this Tuesday. The episode is available by 5 AM EDT.
 |
I’ll leave you with this question to ponder…
What decision have you been half-making for so long that the negotiation has just become part of your daily life?
You deserve to not be having that conversation with yourself every single day. And clarity, even when it’s uncomfortable, is so much lighter than the alternative. Trust me, I know.
There is life beyond the gray,
Kari
P.S. If something in this newsletter stirred something in you and you’re ready to stop figuring it out alone, I’d love to have a real conversation. No pitch, no pressure. Just an honest talk about where you are and where you want to go. Book a call with me HERE.
