Most of us have done things we’re not proud of. Said something we wish we could take back. Shown up in a way that made us cringe the next morning. Had a moment we’d give anything to erase.
And many times, we managed to get through it. We felt the embarrassment, maybe even the shame, and then we moved on. Filed it away and hoped nobody remembers it. Told ourselves it wasn’t that bad, or that everyone does stupid stuff sometimes, or that we’d do better next time.
And then next time came. And the same thing happened again.
All of what I just described was me… for years. And now, I want to share with you why this is so important to tell you why this happens to many of us.
Most of those moments I described don’t actually change us. They embarrass us, yes. They create a hangover of guilt that lasts a day or two. But then life moves forward and we move with it, carrying the same habits and the same patterns, just with one more story we’d rather forget.
So what’s actually different about the moment that finally does something? The one that really sticks? The one that becomes the before-and-after line in someone’s life?
I’ve been asking that question for a long time. And the answer, I’ve come to believe, has almost nothing to do with how bad the moment was. It has everything to do with identity.
Why Embarrassment Alone Rarely Changes Anything
Researchers who study shame and behavior change have found something that might surprise you. Shame, the deep visceral feeling of I am bad, doesn’t actually motivate lasting change. It tends to do the opposite. When we feel profound shame, we hide. We minimize. We find ways to rationalize what happened so we can get back to feeling okay about ourselves as quickly as possible. And then we reach for whatever helps us do that fastest.
That’s the cycle. Something happens. We feel awful. We manage the awful feeling. We move on. Nothing changes.
Guilt works a little differently. Guilt says I did something bad, not I am bad. And research consistently shows that guilt, the kind where you genuinely reckon with the impact of your behavior on yourself and on others, is actually more likely to drive real change. Because guilt keeps the behavior separate from your identity. It says this isn’t who I want to be. And that distinction is what makes an enormous difference.
But even guilt, on its own, often isn’t enough. Because we’re remarkably good at managing guilt too. We apologize. We promise to do better. We mean it in the moment. And then the next hard day comes and the familiar pattern kicks back in because nothing underneath has actually shifted.
The Identity Reality
Here’s what I know from my own life and from sitting with hundreds of people who have been exactly where you might be right now.
Most of the hard moments, the embarrassing ones, the ones that made us feel terrible the next day, they didn’t change us because they didn’t threaten who we believed ourselves to be. We could absorb them. We could file them under ‘bad night’ or ‘not my finest moment’ and keep moving forward with our self-concept basically intact.
But every once in a while, something happens that you can’t file away like that. Not because it’s necessarily the most stupidest thing that’s ever happened. But because it shows you a version of yourself that doesn’t match who you thought you were. Or more specifically, who you thought you were becoming.
That gap, between who you are in that moment and who you know you’re supposed to be, is where real change is happens. Is it comfortable? NO. Is it clean? NO. It often comes with a type of grief that people don’t expect, because you’re not just reckoning with what you did. You’re reckoning with what you’ve allowed yourself to become over time without fully realizing it.
And once you see it, you really can’t unsee it. The mirror has been held up. And you have a choice about what you do with what you’re looking at.
Ouch, I know. And truthfully, it’s the reality check you’ve been needing all along.
The Goalposts We Keep Moving
Before that identity-cracking moment arrives, most of us are playing a inner silent game with ourselves that we don’t even realize we’re playing.
We compare ourselves to people who are doing worse. We tell ourselves it’s not that bad… yet. We set internal thresholds, these invisible lines we swear we’ll never cross, and then when we get close to one, we move it just a little further out. Nothing catastrophic happened so ‘clearly we’re fine’. Other people are doing more than this, right? It’s not affecting my work or my marriage. I’m still showing up! But are you? Really?
That moving of the goalposts is one of the most human things we do. Our brains are wired to prefer familiar discomfort over unfamiliar change. Even unhealthy familiar feels safer than healthy unfamiliar. So we negotiate. We justify. We find evidence that supports staying exactly where we are.
Until the moment we can’t anymore. Until the moment the person looking back at us in that mirror is someone we genuinely don’t recognize.
Your Version of Enough
Everybody has their own version of that moment. It looks completely different from person to person. For a few, it is dramatic. For others it’s something less obvious. It could be a single sentence, a look on someone’s face, or a morning where the weight of everything finally became too heavy to pick up and carry one more time.
What they all have in common is this: the behavior stopped feeling like something they did and started feeling like something they were becoming. And that shift, from “I did this” to “I’m becoming this”, is what finally makes the difference.
The question worth sitting with this week isn’t what has to happen before you’ll make a change. It’s this: who are you becoming? Not who you are on your best days. Who are you becoming on the days when no one’s watching and the old patterns take over? Is that the person you want to be?
You don’t have to wait for life to force the decision. You can choose your own enough before something else chooses it for you. And choosing it yourself, that’s where the real power is. That’s called agency, my friend.
This Week on Beyond the Gray
Episode 22 drops Tuesday and it’s one of the most personal episodes I’ve recorded. I share stories from my own life, the ones I’m not particularly proud of, and the one that finally cracked something open in me. Not because of how bad it was, but because of what it showed me about who I was becoming. I also share three client stories of enough moments that look completely different from mine but carry the same truth underneath.
If you’ve been thinking about something in your own life that you know isn’t serving you anymore, this episode is going to hold up a mirror.
 |
I’ll leave you with this. The version of you that you’re becoming is being created right now, one day and one decision at a time. The question isn’t whether something bad enough will happen to force a change. The question is whether you’re willing to look honestly at what you’re creating before it’s finished.
That’s enough to begin.
Here’s to living beyond the gray,
Kari
P.S. If you’re ready to address what’s really driving your behaviors and you’ve reached your own enough, let’s talk. Trying to figure this out alone can leave you lingering in the gray far longer than necessary. You deserve someone in your corner who’s already been there. Book a call below and let’s get you moving.
| YES, I’M READY! |
Know someone who could benefit from this newsletter? Forward this email to them today. They can subscribe HERE. And thank YOU for being here with me.
